Sadly, none of this is ever about right or wrong or even agreement on the basic facts.
Right now, Europeans are royally pissed at 1) what they see as the US welching on its side of the deal 2) what they regard as massive insults heaped upon them.
The reality is that we in the US will need to fund a much larger percentage of our arms R&D and production and have significantly fewer takers for our products.
The much bigger fear is that we may just be creating 2 world markets:
- the US market in which the US imposes tariffs and essentially protects inefficiency from foreign competition, and
- a bigger market where the rest of the world continues free trade without us. Singapore's PM just gave a compelling speech on this point. His argument is that the US essentially just expelled itself from the WTO, but there is nothing to stop the rest of the WTO's membership continuing without us.
This is a compelling argument. We are already seeing a trading bloc form which includes the English-speaking British Commonwealth, the EU and Japan as a free trade zone, which is approaching twice the size of the US market.