A coupla months back, in another thread about boots, I came across a simple test: grab a boot by the sole in one hand. Place your hand at the top of the upper in the other. Try to move the upper in a circle around the sole which you hold still.
I did this to my trusty 20-year-old Corbin Roadmaster boots that have had three soles on them and are super comfy. Well, no surprise: I could move the upper in a 360 degree circle and bend it all the way flat to the left, right, forward and backward. About as protective as a wet dish cloth.
I also no longer wear my Daytona Arrow Sports for the same reason: comfortable to walk in, but no restriction on hyperextension, ankle rolling, and the top is not tall enough to protect the tibia and fibula.
Bought me some Alpine Toucans which are bulky, stiff to walk any distance in, and squeak like a strangled parrot. AND they protect my feet, ankles and legs. I change into Clarks I keep at work... problem solved.