Half of the CS splines, and half of the sprocket splines, which leads me to believe that the nut may have worked loose at some point in time, chewed up the splines, then the owner re-torqued the nut and it has been marginal till now.
The sprocket that was on there had no markings, but it has a grooved side and a flat side; it was installed with the flat side towards the engine. The one I got (Primary Drive) also has a grooved and a flat side, but it also has markings on the flat side, and the instructions say to install it with the markings facing outwards, which confirms what you were told. So if we apply this to the old sprocket, the flat side should have been facing outwards, which means that it was installed backwards.
Still, I don't see how this would have affected the splines. It may have affected the alignment between front and rear sprocket, but even that would have been marginal: when I reversed the sprocket it didn't look any different than being installed the other way.
Both spacers are flat, not concave.
Moly and blue Loctite I will do, but I have a hard time with seals; will I have to heat up the case and freeze the seal in order to install?
Tough nut?? I can't quite follow.