• There has been a recent cluster of spammers accessing BARFer accounts and posting spam. To safeguard your account, please consider changing your password. It would be even better to take the additional step of enabling 2 Factor Authentication (2FA) on your BARF account. Read more here.

Why do group texts randomly split off into new threads

Reli

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2010
Location
east bay
Moto(s)
01 929
Name
reli
Anyone get this? There's 9-10 people in this group TXT I'm a part of, and sometimes it will branch off into a new thread for no reason. Like all of a sudden there'll be 4-5 threads with pieces of the conversation split up between them. No one seems to know why. The only solution seems to be to delete the new threads and just hope for the best. But it keeps happening.
 
Why not just use Whatsapp? It's actually designed to handle huge groups and conversations...
 
short version: iMessage doesn't deal with non-iMessage users very well. It almost always will try to send imessage every now and then, just because apple.
 
one person switching from an iPhone to not-iPhone and keeping the old chats will cause this. everyone in the group chat must delete it to have any chance of keeping the chat as an SMS instead of iMsg. but itll usually keep happening for up to a year until iMsg forgets that person ever had an iPhone.
 
I know people who still have flip phones/slider phones can make smart phone group texts a nightmare.
 
Anyone get this? There's 9-10 people in this group TXT I'm a part of, and sometimes it will branch off into a new thread for no reason. Like all of a sudden there'll be 4-5 threads with pieces of the conversation split up between them. No one seems to know why. The only solution seems to be to delete the new threads and just hope for the best. But it keeps happening.

Must be something in your computer. Because that never happens to me on Skype.
(well, unless of course it's Microsoft's "Deciding that I'm gonna freeze" daily moment)
 
But why sometimes and not all the time? I mean we post almost 100 messages a day in this thread, but it only happens once every couple days.

100 texts per day and on barf :wow

The Chinese are eating our lunch.
 
one person switching from an iPhone to not-iPhone and keeping the old chats will cause this. everyone in the group chat must delete it to have any chance of keeping the chat as an SMS instead of iMsg. but itll usually keep happening for up to a year until iMsg forgets that person ever had an iPhone.
This.
It seems like it could also happen, with the addition of the ability to remove yourself from a conversation, what happens if other people's phones don't get the memo (have older phone/upgrades) or somebody goes back to an earlier group conversation to send out messages, confusing the whole conversation.

There are quite a few ways for these group conversations to break down, depending how they are tracked at the server.

I've built systems that interact with multiple entities and there are so many possible permutations on what people do that you can't account for all of them.
 
one person switching from an iPhone to not-iPhone and keeping the old chats will cause this. everyone in the group chat must delete it to have any chance of keeping the chat as an SMS instead of iMsg. but itll usually keep happening for up to a year until iMsg forgets that person ever had an iPhone.

They claim they've been using the same phones.

I'm looking at this one guy's iPhone, and in the Settings menu for Messages, there's a checkbox for "Send as SMS when iMessage is unavailable". And there's another checkbox for MMS too. Should both of those be checked?
 
Iphones behave really weird sometimes when texting.
Ive had people text me and ask why I didn't reply. I'll ask in front of me to text my number and show nothing being received on my end.
Then the next morning after having my phone off and charging overnight all the unrecieved text will show up next day.
 
They claim they've been using the same phones.

I'm looking at this one guy's iPhone, and in the Settings menu for Messages, there's a checkbox for "Send as SMS when iMessage is unavailable". And there's another checkbox for MMS too. Should both of those be checked?

even if it's checked, sometimes it doesn't matter.
 
Every iPhone user on the planet should have "Send as SMS/MMS when iMsg is unavailable" enabled, unless they are out of the country or something.
 
Back
Top