• There has been a recent cluster of spammers accessing BARFer accounts and posting spam. To safeguard your account, please consider changing your password. It would be even better to take the additional step of enabling 2 Factor Authentication (2FA) on your BARF account. Read more here.

Tool Guys - Recommend Me a Tool Chest

Craftsman HOME boxes and their first 2-3 non "Home" tier boxes are crap. Once you get to their non-crap boxes you are beyond your budget.

Some of the Costco boxes seem pretty well built but I have never owned one.

I bought a Lowes 42" box and the top chest for $500 about 6 years ago and love it. They recently replaced it in their line up with a new model and were blowing out the old model for pretty cheap.

I also have a 44" HF roll around chest that I use as drawers for hardware under my workbench. It is a decent box but not quite as sturdy as my Lowes box next to it.
 
I don't have anything to contribute other than my reaction: "$300 budget for a tool box?" I can't fathom something like a tool box costing that little. I guess I've been drinking the kool aide too long, ha.

That being said, I have several Snap-on boxes from various eras and have not paid full pop for any of them. I bought 'em all used. I don't understand why someone would sell their tool box but when they do they generally get pennies on the dollar for them.
 
I don't have anything to contribute other than my reaction: "$300 budget for a tool box?" I can't fathom something like a tool box costing that little. I guess I've been drinking the kool aide too long, ha.

That being said, I have several Snap-on boxes from various eras and have not paid full pop for any of them. I bought 'em all used. I don't understand why someone would sell their tool box but when they do they generally get pennies on the dollar for them.

I know right! $300? I spent more than that on my last torque wrench.

I do very much see the ridiculousness in the Snap-On tool condos that cost north of five figures. In the end, it's just a bunch of stamped steel, with no more moving parts or complexity than the stuff for a fraction of its cost. Everything is just a little thicker, tougher, etc. You get to a point of diminishing returns when it comes to these things in terms of quality. And that point is around $1500-2000 I think.
 
For three hundred you will have to step up your craigslist mojo. Here is another alternative. That is seldom mentioned.

I bought a 36 in Equipto box for about 200 bucks. You can search Lista, Equipto, Vidmar to get familiar with them. They sell small to large. Drawers are rated to like 4-500 lbs each, plenty of organization options for them, built to last a life time. The other nice thing is the drawers are very deep. 30 something inches. That means all your long torque wrenches, pry bars, etc fit no problems.

I built a steel framed work bench around the box. Holds all my mechanics tools with ease.

Mine is about this size
used-workbench-stanley-vidmar-1.jpg
 
I know right! $300? I spent more than that on my last torque wrench.

I do very much see the ridiculousness in the Snap-On tool condos that cost north of five figures. In the end, it's just a bunch of stamped steel, with no more moving parts or complexity than the stuff for a fraction of its cost. Everything is just a little thicker, tougher, etc. You get to a point of diminishing returns when it comes to these things in terms of quality. And that point is around $1500-2000 I think.

Some guys on a machinist forum were talking about those Matco Rebel or Revel boxes, I would guess $20,000ish?, and I mentioned that these guys were trying to impress the other guys in the shop, since we all know that there aren't any chicks in machine shops.

And......Torque wrenches. When I worked for Alan Johnson/Al-Anabi Racing, they were sponsored by, at various times, Marco, Snap-On, Travers Tool Company, and MAC Tools (yeah, what a bitch, having to use new, high dollar tools), and there was a drawer with, I would guess, maybe 75 1/2 in drive torque wrenches in it, ranging from new, to a few years old. And one of the guys said, there is a torque tester on the wall, make sure you check whatever one you used. I grab one and check, then another, then another. Out of that drawer, I think there was 2 torque wrenches that were even close. These weren't Harbor Fuckin' Freight. They were the best Snap-On, Matco and Mac had, and I'd say that 85-90% were unusable. After that, I assume that buying the most expensive doesn't guarantee that is is accurate, or will stay accurate. Like my KTM, more or less. They have these precision inch pound jobs where I work now, that are (supposed to be) very accurate, but they cost 10 times as much.

I've got a Craftsman Professional ball bearing bottom box, Proto ball bearing middle box, and a Home Depot cheezass top box. The bottom Craftsman, is decent, but it's a little older, not sure about the newer ones. The Proto is much higher quality, it was one sale and I think we bought 4 of them, $215 ea. The top box is a piece of shit, I had a drawer full of carbide end mills, not extremely heavy, maybe 30 lbs, and it almost wouldn't slide, I ended up putting them in the Proto center box. Oh yeah, I've got a Kennedy hang on side box, sitting on a furniture dolly sitting next to it. My work box.

At home, a Home Depot 42 inch stainless top and bottom, floor model, last one, $215, $250(?), somewhere in there. Total for both. I get it home, the bottom drawer in the top box was broke, I figured it was on sale, but called them anyway, they brought another one in from a different store and replaced it. It was fine for a couple years. I had a drawer with 4 complete sets of sockets, several ratchets, a whole bunch of loose sockets, probably close to 100 of them, I would guess there was 40 lbs in it. My wife walks by it, the drawer was open, she might have brushed it, just barely, and it collapses inward, and rips the ball bearing slides off the walls of the cabinet, and all the sockets spilled out on the floor. In my opinion, the drawer is too long, it was full length, the sheet metal too thin, it kinked in the middle and pulled the side walls in. I straightened the drawer, remounted the slides on the cabinet, and I don't put much in the drawer any more. And I've got the Harbor Freight tools caddy thing, with the open bottom and about 6 drawers, it is very heavy duty, with ball bearing slides, got it on a trade, and another Craftsman bottom , and another Home Depot top, plus, another Craftsman, real old bottom but not ball bearing, very heavy duty also, with a compound miter saw bolted to it.

Yeah, I have a tool issue.
 
For three hundred you will have to step up your craigslist mojo. Here is another alternative. That is seldom mentioned.

I bought a 36 in Equipto box for about 200 bucks. You can search Lista, Equipto, Vidmar to get familiar with them. They sell small to large. Drawers are rated to like 4-500 lbs each, plenty of organization options for them, built to last a life time. The other nice thing is the drawers are very deep. 30 something inches. That means all your long torque wrenches, pry bars, etc fit no problems.

I built a steel framed work bench around the box. Holds all my mechanics tools with ease.

Mine is about this size
used-workbench-stanley-vidmar-1.jpg

We had those where I used to work. But the 6 foot high models. Ours were Lista, each drawer has a 440lb capacity. $3000 or so. I wish I could have those, they're baaaaaadddddaaaaaassss.
 
We had those where I used to work. But the 6 foot high models. Ours were Lista, each drawer has a 440lb capacity. $3000 or so. I wish I could have those, they're baaaaaadddddaaaaaassss.

They are out there on craigslist. You just have to keep your eye out for them. Most people have no idea what they are, most people are focused on Snap On eye candy. Id love a snap on roller, but dollar for dollar, these lista/vidmar types blow them out of the water if you don't need it to be portable.
 
They are out there on craigslist. You just have to keep your eye out for them. Most people have no idea what they are, most people are focused on Snap On eye candy. Id love a snap on roller, but dollar for dollar, these lista/vidmar types blow them out of the water if you don't need it to be portable.

440 lb per drawer capacity. The more weight, the better they slide.
 
I had a drawer full of carbide end mills, not extremely heavy, maybe 30 lbs, and it almost wouldn't slide,


My wife walks by it, the drawer was open, she might have brushed it, just barely, and it collapses inward, and rips the ball bearing slides off the walls of the cabinet, and all the sockets spilled out on the floor. In my opinion, the drawer is too long, it was full length, the sheet metal too thin, it kinked in the middle and pulled the side walls in.

I know you know this, but just for anyone else who's curious...

That's really the fundamental difference between a $500 box and a $5000 box...load capacity. I see guys constantly who will slide a drawer that has a shitload of tools in it all the way open, then sit on the front of it to take a break. They'd never dare do that on a cheap box because we all know the result.

The guy buying the $500 rig usually doesn't have that many tools. They know that, so they use thinner sheet metal, weaker slides, casters, and so on. This is why the $5000 box weighs about half a ton empty, and the $500 one doesn't even weigh that much with all of the owner's tools in it.
 
Last edited:
440 lb per drawer capacity. The more weight, the better they slide.

I have to think my most expensive tools combined weigh less than 150lbs. indicators, mic's, calipers, gauge blocks, pin gauges from .060" to .500" , 1-2-3 blocks, mag bases and most other inspection and measuring tools just are not that massive. I guess if you have your own 40" height gauge and granite surface plate you are going to need somethng special but for me, my 15 year old craftsman ball bering box has been just fine for work. One of the best machinists I know has a home made wooden tool box as his work unit and its rad.

Fancy tool boxes are great if you can afford them. But i think they are often bought to impress other guys in the shop.

Edit, holy shit i didnt realize how bananas tool boxes have got. This it fucking recockulous.

https://sfbay.craigslist.org/eby/tls/6089933318.html

https://sfbay.craigslist.org/sby/tls/6089532329.html
 
Last edited:
For three hundred you will have to step up your craigslist mojo. Here is another alternative. That is seldom mentioned.

I bought a 36 in Equipto box for about 200 bucks. You can search Lista, Equipto, Vidmar to get familiar with them. They sell small to large. Drawers are rated to like 4-500 lbs each, plenty of organization options for them, built to last a life time. The other nice thing is the drawers are very deep. 30 something inches. That means all your long torque wrenches, pry bars, etc fit no problems.

I built a steel framed work bench around the box. Holds all my mechanics tools with ease.
Dude, thanks for posting this, i have limited space and this works for me. also, +1 on the kennedy, bought it from costco, 20+ yrs., no issues at all...
 
Fancy tool boxes are great if you can afford them. But i think they are often bought to impress other guys in the shop.

I no longer get impressed with that. Some of the laziest, most incompetent techs I've ever worked with started their time with me by having a flatbed drop off their enormous triple bank/hutch/locker $25k+ (empty) setup to the shop.
 
I no longer get impressed with that. Some of the laziest, most incompetent techs I've ever worked with started their time with me by having a flatbed drop off their enormous triple bank/hutch/locker $25k+ (empty) setup to the shop.

Dude, I didn't think you could spend north of 25 THOUSAND dollars for a sheet metal box. That kind of money can buy good used machine tools.

The Two C/L links i posted blew my mind.
 
Looks like the costco one is $600. Best tool box ever? No way, but for what it cost i think it's solid enough.
 
Last edited:
I have to think my most expensive tools combined weigh less than 150lbs. indicators, mic's, calipers, gauge blocks, pin gauges from .060" to .500" , 1-2-3 blocks, mag bases and most other inspection and measuring tools just are not that massive. I guess if you have your own 40" height gauge and granite surface plate you are going to need somethng special but for me, my 15 year old craftsman ball bering box has been just fine for work. One of the best machinists I know has a home made wooden tool box as his work unit and its rad.

Fancy tool boxes are great if you can afford them. But i think they are often bought to impress other guys in the shop.

Edit, holy shit i didnt realize how bananas tool boxes have got. This it fucking recockulous.

https://sfbay.craigslist.org/eby/tls/6089933318.html

https://sfbay.craigslist.org/sby/tls/6089532329.html

Cash only? That doesn't seem sketchy at all.
 
Dude, I didn't think you could spend north of 25 THOUSAND dollars for a sheet metal box. That kind of money can buy good used machine tools.

The Two C/L links i posted blew my mind.

Here is currently the biggest and most expensive single box in the Snap-On catalog...

KEXN725B0PJH.jpg


If you get it with the SS top and remote locking (yes that's a thing), it'll set you back a cool $30k. It is 12 feet wide. Absurdity level 9000 for sure.

A lot of pro race teams went for the "tool wagon" which I don't think Snap-On even sells anymore. These were almost $30k if you got them in their biggest size like this one. Notice how big it is compared to the actual tool truck...

post-222-1355194611.jpg



Either way, you're probably storing close to $100k worth of tools in them and you're Snap-On dealer loves you so much that you probably get Christmas cards from him.
 
A few years ago I remember seeing a bad ass older Matco box for 500 or 600, just save and wait, money talks and bullshit walks. I like having most of my go to stuff mounted on the wall with pegboard. For 50 bucks you can get a lot pegboard, hooks, etc.
 
Here is currently the biggest and most expensive single box in the Snap-On catalog...

KEXN725B0PJH.jpg


If you get it with the SS top and remote locking (yes that's a thing), it'll set you back a cool $30k. It is 12 feet wide. Absurdity level 9000 for sure.

A lot of pro race teams went for the "tool wagon" which I don't think Snap-On even sells anymore. These were almost $30k if you got them in their biggest size like this one. Notice how big it is compared to the actual tool truck...

post-222-1355194611.jpg



Either way, you're probably storing close to $100k worth of tools in them and you're Snap-On dealer loves you so much that you probably get Christmas cards from him.

I used to always laugh at the chuckle-head dudes I worked with boarding that Snap-On truck and coming out with payment plans for tools they could never afford.
 
Back
Top