• There has been a recent cluster of spammers accessing BARFer accounts and posting spam. To safeguard your account, please consider changing your password. It would be even better to take the additional step of enabling 2 Factor Authentication (2FA) on your BARF account. Read more here.

My recent experience with Spot SOS feature

Great intel! Amazing that the human error, and game of telephone factors cannot be negated, even when doing so is the primary purpose of the company. You are your own best resource... so ride safely :)

I think this is really one of the key learnings here for me. I was always naively under the impression that if/when I ever had to use the SOS button, that someone would receive the distress call, make a phone call, and help would be on the way. The reality is that the response will likely involve a chain of communication across several government agencies, and may break down or be delayed at any of those hand-offs. I'd much rather be in control of the chain of communication myself with a sat phone, than rely on someone else to do it for me.
 
The failure here seems to be CA EMA. If they are responsible to respond to SPOT alerts then they should respond without hesitation. To me they sound like the Coast Guard of CA (inland). I know damn good and well that the CG would never not respond immediately once an Epirb was detected. Regardless if it was an accident or not. They start the response while they attempt to contact the vessel as any delay could be the difference between life or death. There is simply no excuse for CA EMA to not do the same.

Once a SPOT alert is given they should try to contact the number provided for confirmation. If no answer then immediately notify CA EMA, give them the GPS location of which EMA should immediately contact the local EMS and have them respond. Simple as that. Failure to react in this way could and should hold the CA EMA responsible for any death or injury proven worsened by lack of a timely response. There is simply no excuse for anything less.
 
Thank you for sharing the story. I don't understand why GEOS would not call the emergency number (911 equivalent) for the city nearest to the SPOT that was activated.
 
I'm sure there are so many false alarms (boy who cried wolf syndrome) that 911 operators don't even want to pursue blind SOS transmissions. It's like cops and missing persons reports, too many resources are wasted unless they are reasonable certainty that help is actually needed.
 
I'm sure there are so many false alarms (boy who cried wolf syndrome) that 911 operators don't even want to pursue blind SOS transmissions. It's like cops and missing persons reports, too many resources are wasted unless they are reasonable certainty that help is actually needed.

Don't make excuses. The whole point of a SPOT is to save your life if you need to use the SOS feature. Your expectations should be a quick and decisive emergency response and nothing less. It's a failure if they fail to provide an emergency response in a timely manor.

I doubt there are many false alarms of this type of system. People that decide they need an SOS device know what they are buying. The response should be immediate until proven no need not the other way around. We are talking a potential life threatening situation here. Its very doubtful that someone would use the SOS feature if they run out of gas and even if they do they have to pay for the response they get. So it's a moot point as far as EMS is concerned.

Sorry if I seem emotional on this but I spent almost 10 years in the Coast Guard and SAR is something that I feel is important. The OP's description of the response he got from the SPOT simply appalls me. Under no circumstances should there had been a delay to his SOS from CA EMA. I just hope other states have a better response effort. I know if I was the one at EMA that got the call I would do everything in my power to get the ball rolling. Failure to do so is to set yourself up for lawsuits galore.
 
Last edited:
I thought police always respond no matter what. Like when if you call 911 and then leave the phone off the hook and don't say anything.

What is the point of using the SPOT if they don't respond because the responders think it might be a waste of their time?
 
The "who's on first" routine by the different organizations in the emergency response chain remains a concern. I've used the SPOT 911 functionality twice, and both times emergency response was successfully summoned quickly, and arrived sooner than would have been possible otherwise. (most recent one)

In that last one, the disconnect between the agencies seemed equally shaky. SPOT called GEOS, GEOS called someone in CA, someone in CA got in touch with the Sheriffs office and the local police, the local police and fire then showed up on scene (12 minutes total from button press to arrival).

But there is no quarterback managing that call, so the Sheriff's office still thought the call was live, for quite a long time after everything had been resolved. They were still in contact with my wife, and they even suggested that she take a drive up to see if things were resolved. While out of cell coverage, the location is still only about 20 - 25 minutes from home. The Sheriffs office evidently didn't know that the police/fire were on scene, and the police/fire didn't know that they had anyone else to let know that the call had been answered. So my wife ended up taking a nice drive up to check, and by the time she arrived they had cleaned everything up and they let her know what had happened (and that I had gone on my way for the rest of the ride). I had also sent an OK message as soon as emergency help did arrive, so SPOT was aware, or could have been aware, that all was OK. But that OK message doesn't seem to have a path to get down the chain to all the emergency responders that may have been contacted. By the time I returned to a location that had cell service, I only then realized the wild goose chase she was sent on, and was able to call her directly. Based on prior experience, she wasn't particularly stressed or worried, as logic dictates that if my SPOT device is the one that someone pressed 911 on, odds are I'm not the one in immediate need of help.

I really appreciate having the ability to get a message out from anywhere, and wouldn't ride without it. SPOT's become the defacto emergency response / tracking device for long distance motorcyclists, and will be carried by the vast majority of the iron butt competitors this year; the fact that we don't have to keep fuel logs if we're running a SPOT in tracking mode is certainly a large driver as well. :)

I'd certainly welcome 2-way communication capabilities at a similar price point. Would also be interested to hear suggestions/recommendations for SPOT/GEOS/EMA/Local communication to be handled in a more trustable way. It would be depressing if the technology continued to work reliably yet the process behind the scenes didn't.
 
Last edited:
... contacted the California OEM (Office of Emergency Management) which is their policy for any SOS call in California, and relayed all the information about the incident at 3:58 (about 8 minutes after the original SOS). According to the lady at GEOS I spoke with today, this is technically where their responsibility ends. However, the dispatcher went further and contacted the San Benito County Sherriff’s office at 4:10PM and advised them that they would be contacted by the CA OEM. What the California OEM and San Benito County Sherriff’s office did in the next 40 minutes is a mystery. The GEOS dispatcher eventually received a call at 4:40PM from the CA OEM advising him that Cal Fire was on scene. GEOS received another call later confirming that AMR was on scene. Each time GEOS received these updates they promptly relayed them to my wife...

I'm sure there are shortcoming in the system but from this description is seems like everyone did their job. Only conjecture here but Ca OEM and San Benito Sherriff office most likely did when they heard of the accident is check to see if it was being responded to. They then told GEOS that help was on the scene. Where is the breakdown here? Yes there is passing from agency to agency and some lag there but your accident was covered. Your rider got to the Fire dept before the call from GEOS etc disseminated. I'm assuming the Sherriff dept can see dispatch records without making a second call to Cal Fire dispatch. The 1-way communication of the device and GEOS inability to give details to your wife are both big considerations but it does not mean that rescue response was faulty.
 
I'm sure there are shortcoming in the system but from this description is seems like everyone did their job. Only conjecture here but Ca OEM and San Benito Sherriff office most likely did when they heard of the accident is check to see if it was being responded to. They then told GEOS that help was on the scene. Where is the breakdown here? Yes there is passing from agency to agency and some lag there but your accident was covered. Your rider got to the Fire dept before the call from GEOS etc disseminated. I'm assuming the Sherriff dept can see dispatch records without making a second call to Cal Fire dispatch. The 1-way communication of the device and GEOS inability to give details to your wife are both big considerations but it does not mean that rescue response was faulty.

Based on the information I have so far, I can't say definitively that their response was faulty, but it was definitely slow. Hence my conclusion further down in the same paragraph that you quoted, that " In the end, I still have to believe that the SOS call to Spot/GEOS would have eventually resulted in a response, but it would have taken significantly longer than the 2 hours it took to get the rider transported out."
 
I'm sure there are shortcoming in the system but from this description is seems like everyone did their job. Only conjecture here but Ca OEM and San Benito Sherriff office most likely did when they heard of the accident is check to see if it was being responded to. They then told GEOS that help was on the scene. Where is the breakdown here? Yes there is passing from agency to agency and some lag there but your accident was covered. Your rider got to the Fire dept before the call from GEOS etc disseminated. I'm assuming the Sherriff dept can see dispatch records without making a second call to Cal Fire dispatch. The 1-way communication of the device and GEOS inability to give details to your wife are both big considerations but it does not mean that rescue response was faulty.

The lag is the concerning part. OP stated that a rider left to find help after they all stood around a bit and discussed what to do. He found help 11 miles down the road. I would venture to guess that is roughly 15 minutes from button push to finding help. The ambulance said they never received notice of the accident. I would expect SPOT to have somebody rolling within 5 minutes of pressing the button, and even that is not satisfactory.
 
The new DeLorme InReach SE doesn't require a smartphone to SMS, so this is likely the route I'm going to go.

Thanks very much for the write up; great info!

I agree that 2-way communication (text) would be so much better. I got the following rates from TheGPSStore.com - The "Safety Plan" would be all I need, and the rates seem reasonable compared to SPOT. The only thing is, from reading Amazon user reviews, these devices havne't achieved the user friendiless and realiability we've grown accustom to from main stream consumer electronics.

DeLorme InReach SE
Monthly Service Plans

Safety Plan - Unlimited SOS, 10 Messages per month, No Tracking, $9.95 per Month.
Overage - $1.50 per message and $0.25 per Track.


Recreation Plan - Unlimited SOS, 40 Messages per month, Unlimited Tracking, $24.95 per Month.
Overage - $0.50 per message.

Expedition Plan - Unlimited SOS, 120 Messages per month, Unlimited Tracking, $49.95 per Month.
Overage - $0.25 per message.

There is a one-time $11.95 activation charge.

http://www.thegpsstore.com/Delorme-inReach-SE.aspx
 
Absolutely. And every extra second an injured person has to sit there matters. And your write up on the experience is great in determining if you want to use/rely on a Spot. My takeaway is that it is still reliable, especially if you are a solo rider, but that sending a person for help is always going to be more direct and quicker. Knowing that it works this way is invaluable information in making a decision or even having an expectation of how it will work/time involved if you do end up needing it...
And as I said the other considerations are also big factors. All the chatter lately of ICE and Spot has got me talking and coordinating with my wife about these things as well and it's hard enough talking to her about the potentials of an accident I cannot imagine how thrown she'd be if she had to sit there for 3 hours imagining the worst.
 
Thanks very much for the write up; great info!

I agree that 2-way communication (text) would be so much better. I got the following rates from TheGPSStore.com - The "Safety Plan" would be all I need, and the rates seem reasonable compared to SPOT. The only thing is, from reading Amazon user reviews, these devices havne't achieved the user friendiless and realiability we've grown accustom to from main stream consumer electronics.

DeLorme InReach SE
Monthly Service Plans

Safety Plan - Unlimited SOS, 10 Messages per month, No Tracking, $9.95 per Month.
Overage - $1.50 per message and $0.25 per Track.


Recreation Plan - Unlimited SOS, 40 Messages per month, Unlimited Tracking, $24.95 per Month.
Overage - $0.50 per message.

Expedition Plan - Unlimited SOS, 120 Messages per month, Unlimited Tracking, $49.95 per Month.
Overage - $0.25 per message.

There is a one-time $11.95 activation charge.

http://www.thegpsstore.com/Delorme-inReach-SE.aspx

Thanks for posting the rate plans. So that's $299 msrp for the unit and $10/mo for SOS and occasional texts? Sounds like the lowest cost option of everything mentioned in this thread other than a plain beacon.

I've glossed over the satellite technologies involved... I assume the SOS signal will be persistent, but what is the reliability of one-off texts and the Iridium network?
 
first aid

- At least two of us were first-aid/CPR trained but nobody had a first aid kit suitable for the types of injuries you might need to deal with in the field. A few people had first aid kits with band-aids, gauze, alcohol wipes, etc. but these are only marginally useful in a real emergency. Thankfully we didn’t need supplies in this incident, but it has caused me to reassess my level of preparedness when venturing out into remote locations.

My riding buddy and I have each suffered broken bones while riding--and to that end, I'll definitely be adding a SAM splint, an ACE bandage and crushable ice pack to my first aid kit.

So what else should a beefed-up kit contain besides the usual and the following?
  • splint
  • bandages
  • ice pack
 
The Iridium network is considered to be the most reliable of the satellite networks. Far better than the Globalstar network that Spot uses.

I've pre-ordered my DeLorme InReach SE. They're back-ordered until mid/late June.

Anyone want a gen 1 Spot? :teeth
 
So what else should a beefed-up kit contain besides the usual and the following?
  • splint
  • bandages
  • ice pack

Off the top of my head:

- QuikClot
- a few pairs of rubber gloves
- maybe a tourniquet - but only if you know how/when to use it and only for situations where you absolutely cannot control the bleeding any other way long enough for EMS to arrive.
- a pocket mask of some sort for mouth-to-mouth CPR
 
Thanks. Yes, it's true that some of the newer Spot's allow you to send customized OK messages. The main problem with these is that they're all still 1-way devices. The way they work is that, in order to maximize the likelihood that the SOS is transmitted successfully they broadcast it multiple times every several minutes. Since you have no way of knowing if/when the SOS has successfully transmitted, you have to let it sit transmitting the SOS for a good long while. If you send an SOS, and then send a custom OK to tell your spouse you're fine, the SOS stops broadcasting. If you have a 2-way device you can get positive confirmation that the SOS has gone through, and you can be simultaneously SMS'ing with others. The new DeLorme InReach SE doesn't require a smartphone to SMS, so this is likely the route I'm going to go.

BTW - great meeting you on Sunday. Hopefully we'll meet up again some time.

I didn't read the whole thread so I apologize if this has already been said. My wife and I have discussed this issue and decided that if I ever needed to send an SOS signal for somebody else, I would FIRST send an OK signal (that she would presumably receive).
 
I didn't read the whole thread so I apologize if this has already been said. My wife and I have discussed this issue and decided that if I ever needed to send an SOS signal for somebody else, I would FIRST send an OK signal (that she would presumably receive).

The problem with this is that, in order to ensure that the OK message gets out, the Spot will transmit it 3 times over a 20 minute period. This means that you can't really be sure the OK got out unless you let it sit broadcasting the OK for 20 minutes. This means you will delay calling for help for 20 minutes. Help or SOS calls take priority over OK calls, so if you press the help or SOS button before the 20 minutes and the OK had not yet transmitted successfully, the OK will stop sending and the Help or SOS will be sent instead. Without having a closed-loop system of knowing that a message was transmitted successfully, you need to sit and let the entire broadcast cycle complete, thus delaying calling for help.
 
The problem with this is that, in order to ensure that the OK message gets out, the Spot will transmit it 3 times over a 20 minute period. This means that you can't really be sure the OK got out unless you let it sit broadcasting the OK for 20 minutes. This means you will delay calling for help for 20 minutes. Help or SOS calls take priority over OK calls, so if you press the help or SOS button before the 20 minutes and the OK had not yet transmitted successfully, the OK will stop sending and the Help or SOS will be sent instead. Without having a closed-loop system of knowing that a message was transmitted successfully, you need to sit and let the entire broadcast cycle complete, thus delaying calling for help.

I'm all out of suggestions, then. :laughing
 
Here's a quick follow-up based on some additional discussions today:

GEOS called me again today (yes, they called me) to see if I still had concerns about the response. We talked through the sequence of events again. I have to say I'm pretty impressed with GEOS' response, both during the incident and in their follow-up with me afterwards. I then called the San Benito County Sheriff PSAP (public safety answering point) and spoke to them again about their response.

It appears as though the chain of response was moving in the right direction:

- GEOS called me. No Answer
- GEOS called my wife. Talked to her for several minutes.
- GEOS called Cal EMA at 8 minutes post-SOS. Informed them of the event.
- GEOS called San Benito Sheriff at 11 min post-SOS. Informed them of the event and relayed all information (GPS coordinates, info from my wife, etc.). They recommended contacting the BLM to see if anyone was in the area.
- GEOS contacted BLM. No resources were within radio range.
- GEOS called back to SB Sheriff PSAP. By this point, they had already found out that Cal Fire was responding.

From there, we know the Cal Fire and AMR response.

Based on all of this, it sounds like GEOS was all over it, but was having to juggle multiple agencies in CA. By the time they figured out who was going to send resources, Cal Fire had already responded.

Moral of this story: Spot/GEOS appears to work as advertised but may be slowed, based on how many government agencies they have to interact with to coordinate a response. If you have the resources to pursue parallel paths in an emergency, do so.

As an aside, I talked to the GEOS dispatcher for a while about hardware. He was quick to support the Spot as a good tool, primarily because it's foolproof... you just push the button. If, however you willing to deal with the added complexity of a 2-way device like the DeLorme, he says that response effectiveness goes up tremendously. Not only can they tell you what they're doing, but they can get valuable information from you about what exactly the emergency is. As an example, my wife told them that there were ~40 of us out riding that day. That's all the information she had to give them, so they didn't know if they were dealing with one victim or 40. If it had been multiple victims and they had rolled on scene with one ambulance initially, it would have been an even longer wait for the other victims.

All interesting things to ponder as you think through how you plan to respond to situations in the future.
 
It's super awesome to get this level of insight into how this works. Thanks again for sharing. :thumbup
 
Yes, thank you for the follow up info. It's all very helpful.

Since we're discussing all options, let's say something happens to me and I'm unable to actively push a button or otherwise communicate... will a beacon like the ResQ Link still send a passive signal to aid in a search? Will any of the others (Spot Messenger, DeLorme InReach, satellite phones)?
 
Last edited:
It's super awesome to get this level of insight into how this works. Thanks again for sharing. :thumbup

This.

Also, JPK, your insight on knowing about ALL the possible rescue/response/medical options in a particular area is a damn good one. For example, next time I ride in Colorado, I'll be looking up the fire stations, ranger stations, etc. as well as local hospitals beforehand. The idea that one's own GPS is a wealth of local medical resources is a good thing to remember, as well.

Excellent to coordinate parallel rescue efforts that turned out to be faster than the SPOT/local agency response could be; I can see why the seeming lack of response was upsetting in the first place, though. Sometimes good old fashioned first aid and legwork are the way to go.

It's easy to start to have expectations that we're owed a fast, coordinated rescue if we have SPOT devices and cell phones, these days. In reality, we've bought a service from a private company, but it's still one or more public agencies (likely underfunded and understaffed) that end up doing rescues. The SPOT is just one more tool that might help in a tough situation.
 
Back
Top