I am 95% ATGATT.
I have, on occasion worn all my gear, except for my leather, armored pants. When not wearing those, I'm wearing armored knee/shin guards under Carhartt work pants.
Everything else is my regular moto gear.
(track jacket with spine armor, heavily armored track boots and gloves, full-face helmet)
I started out ATGATT, due to the insistence of all of my friends who rode and my instructors at MSF. After 15 years of riding, I feel naked riding without it–even in the Carhartts. (Which makes me feel even more reluctant to ever go on the Vampires Kilt/Naked rides.)
Now, a story:
I have always worn heavily armored (read:racetrack/moto-x gear) gear. I have full length A* Tech-8 enduro boots and Dainese Torque RS boots.
I was involved in a major side-impact while wearing the enduro boots on the street. Snapped my foot peg off and crushed the shit out of my leg, but nothing broke*. I was unable to walk for over a month. I attribute my luck heavily to the fact that I was wearing hard-armored boots.
Just over a month ago, a good friend was not so fortunate. She was wearing motorcycle boots (but only with a small, internal heel-cup for armor) when she was t-boned at an intersection by a left-turn bandit cager at about 25-35mph.
Here is the result:
View attachment 457731View attachment 457732
Yup. That's the stump where a leg used to be.
(
How it happened)
The boot pic is where a piece of car went through the soft part of the boot and smashed the heel to pieces. There was so much damage that the blood vessels couldn't deliver blood about halfway past the knee, so that's where they amputated from.
Would a heavier armored boot have made a difference? Maybe. Maybe not.
Would you rather have that extra percentage of advantage where it might save your leg? Your hands? Your face below the chin? I sure as hell would.
I rode in 95 degree weather in full-black leathers in NYC when I lived there. People looked at me like I was crazy. I don't care. As the saying goes, "I'd rather sweat than bleed". If I can't wear my gear, I'm driving. Taking a cab. The bus. Walking. It's just not worth the risk (to me).
Everyone else is entitled to wear as little or as much gear as they like. For me, I'm ATG95%OTT. I'm not going to lie and say I don't break the rules, every now and again, but man, am I distracted when doing it. Not safe by any means.
*dislocated the hell out of my knee, though.